Archive for ‘India alert’

10/08/2014

Modi has realised that India needs to be a regional power before it can be a global one

One of the many pet projects of those inclined more to the right has been turning the dream of “Akhand Bharat“, or Undivided India, into a reality. The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh’s education saffroniser-in-chief, Dinanath Batra, has even written about the subject in his book Tejomay Bharat, which will now be stocked in Gujarat school libraries. “Undivided India is the truth, divided India is a lie,” Batra writes, referring to a vision of the nation that begins as far west as Afghanistan and goes all the way till Burma, including everything in between. “Division of India is unnatural and it can be united again,” Batra suggests.

Of course, no one in the government has spoken of Akhand Bharat and Prime Minister Narendra Modi has never clearly explained his understanding of the concept. There is no indication that the government intends to implement any policy that aims to reinstate this fanciful notion of what India once was and there is no reason to believe there will be.

But the concept could be a rubric by which to understand the Modi government’s approach to foreign policy, particularly in the neighbourhood. From the very get-go Modi announced his intention to reinvigorate ties with India’s neighbours by inviting to his swearing-in ceremony each of the leaders from the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation — the primary multilateral forum for subcontinental nations.

Just two-and-a-half-months in, the PM has visited two of India’s neighbours, his foreign minister has visited four, and India is set to become part of multilateral organisations that will give it many more opportunities to project itself as a regional powerhouse. This is Akhand Bharat 2.0.

Regional power

Foreign minister Sushma Swaraj is currently in Myanmar, the fourth neighbourhood country that she has visited in the last three months. But it was the trip made by Modi to Nepal that really sent a statement, since it was the first visit by an Indian prime minister to the country in 17 years. He received an enthusiastic reception.

“All governments that come to power in India feel that we must improve our relationship with the neighbourhood,” said Kanwal Sibal, a former foreign secretary. “But the difference is that, whereas in the past it remained at the level of rhetoric, in this case they are translating it into concrete initiatives. The fact that an Indian PM visited Nepal after 17 years is a testimony to the fact that, despite our professed position about needing a secure neighbourhood, we have actually neglected it… that is changing.”

That message was sent at the very beginning with the invitations handed out to each of the SAARC leaders for Modi’s swearing-in, all of which were accepted — with the exception of Bangladesh’s Sheikh Hasina, but only because she was on another diplomatic visit at the time. The sight of all the leaders in front of Rashtrapati Bhavan, and Modi dedicating his first day in office to bilateral talks with them, sent a very clear signal. The PM made his first foreign visit to Bhutan, a country deeply connected to India but not particularly important in terms of foreign policy.

“It shows that they understand that unless India is a dominant regional power, we can hardly be an extra-regional power or a world power,” said Manoj Joshi, a distinguished fellow at the Observer Research Foundation. “They seem to definitely be working on this understanding, especially because we are facing stiff competition from the Chinese when it comes to projecting power in the neighbourhood.”

Leading South Asia

It’s not just symbolism and rhetoric either. Modi’s visits to Bhutan and Nepal have been accompanied by important agreements, such as a $1 billion line of credit to Kathmandu, as well as the promise of further talks. Discussions with Bangladesh have also indicated progress on key stumbling blocks between the two nations. Modi has also spoken of using the SAARC framework to further cooperation in the neighbourhood. His suggestion of a SAARC space satellite, for example, while criticised by some as a gimmick, certainly sent a message that he is looking beyond the potential disputes towards projects that would allow the countries to work together.

“He has staked his leadership of the region, and this is important,” Sibal said. “There is a gesture to friendship in the neighbourhood, but he has also put across the message that India is leading the region. India is not going to neglect its neighbourhood, and it will take the lead in creating synergies that can benefit all.”

via Scroll.in – News. Politics. Culture..

08/08/2014

Rats On Planes — A Distressingly Common Problem – India Real Time – WSJ

After a rat was discovered aboard an Air India Ltd. plane at the Delhi airport, a spokesman for the country’s state-owned flag carrier said rodent stowaways are a “rare occurrence.”

If only that were true. In fact, rats and other pests often find their way onto jetliners in India and around the world.

With thousands of flights each day handling large quantities of food for passengers as well as baggage, rodents and insects sometimes manage to hitch a ride on food catering trucks or luggage trollies to get inside planes despite hygiene checks.

“We get requests to fumigate four or five planes each month,” said an official of India’s state-run Central Warehousing Corp., which offers pest-control services to airlines, ports, railways, shipping companies and government offices in India.

The official, who declined to be named, said Central Warehousing offers two types of pest treatment to airlines. The most common is spraying pesticides inside aircraft cabins to keep out mosquitoes, cockroaches and other insects.

“The second is fumigation and it is done only when a rat or rat droppings are spotted inside an aircraft,” he said.

Fumigating an aircraft isn’t easy. The plane needs to be isolated, sealed and then pumped full of lethal gas. After about six hours, the aircraft is ventilated to clear the toxic fumes.

The official said the fumigation procedure was carried out on the Air India Airbus A321 that had rodent issues this week. The official said he wasn’t sure whether there was one or more rats inside the plane.

An Air India official had said there was only one rat inside the Airbus A321 jet when it landed at New Delhi on a flight from the eastern metropolis of Kolkata. He denied a Times of India report that said there were “scores” of rats inside the plane.

Pests afflict all airlines. A pest-control company in Southeast Asia said his company has helped clear rats out of planes belonging to two Asian airlines. But airline companies like to keep such matters quiet, and often ask exterminators to sign confidentiality agreements, he said.

The Central Warehousing official said the company’s pest control business for Indian carriers suffered a setback after Kingfisher Airlines stopped flying in 2012 but is now optimistic that business will rebound as new airlines like AirAsia India Pvt.  and Tata SIA Airlines Ltd. set up base in the country.

via Rats On Planes — A Distressingly Common Problem – India Real Time – WSJ.

07/08/2014

Rahul Gandhi Wakes Up to New Role as Rebel Leader – India Real Time – WSJ

There’s nothing particularly newsworthy about boisterous Indian lawmakers blocking debate on the floor of Parliament when they don’t get their way, unless one of the lawmakers is the usually-reticent Rahul Gandhi.

The typically uninvolved Parliamentary back-bencher and Congress party vice president made the front pages of Indian newspapers Thursday after he and others mobbed the desk of the lower house of Parliament’s speaker, demanding to be heard.

“Rip Van Winkle Rahul Finally Rises Out of Slumber,” read an Economic Times headline paired with a recent photograph of Mr. Gandhi nodding off during a parliamentary session.

Mr. Gandhi, who is part of a diminished Congress camp of 44 representatives in the 545-member Lok Sabha, also made a rare statement to reporters outside Parliament complaining that opposition parties were not being allowed to speak. He accused speaker Sumitra Mahajan of bias after she shot down a proposal to discuss recent communal violence.

“There is a mood in Parliament that only one man’s voice counts,” Mr. Gandhi said in an apparent reference to Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

On the campaign trail a few months ago, Mr. Gandhi had said a Modi-led government would polarize Indians and trigger religious unrest.

Mr. Gandhi’s outburst was described as “surprisingly belligerent” in the Times of India that also carried a front-page story about what they called his “new-found combativeness.”

The fourth-generation scion’s occasional public outbursts are closely covered by the national media. In October when he called an executive order by his own party’s government “complete nonsense,” his tantrum was reported, discussed and debated for days.

On Wednesday, television news channels questioned what may have prompted a reaction from a leader who in his decade-long career in Parliament has rarely engaged in debate or taken the lead on policy issues.

The governing Bharatiya Janata Party offered one theory.

Finance Minister Arun Jaitley said Mr. Gandhi’s show of aggression was a result of internal rumblings – a “palace coup” – in the beleaguered Congress that is struggling to bounce back after its worst ever electoral defeat in national elections.

The party’s dynastic leadership by president Sonia Gandhi and her son, Rahul, must be struggling and Mr. Gandhi’s actions Wednesday were an attempt “to show they are also capable of aggression,” Mr. Jaitley said.

Congress spokesman Randeep Singh Surjewala said there “wasn’t an iota of doubt or question” within his party on the Gandhis’ leadership. Some “disgruntled elements hankering for immediate power” had abandoned the Congress after the electoral defeat, Mr. Surjewala said, but added that his party had weathered numerous challenges in the past and, like before, would emerge stronger.

He said the Modi-led government couldn’t run away from a discussion on religious violence by making personal attacks against Congress or its leaders.

via Rahul Gandhi Wakes Up to New Role as Rebel Leader – India Real Time – WSJ.

07/08/2014

The BJP’s real opposition turns out to be a far-Left-far-Right combination

When the final results of the general election were tallied up, it was hard not to marvel at the sheer size of the Bharatiya Janata Party’s victory and the unprecedented defeated delivered to the Indian National Congress. With the BJP emerging not just as the single largest party but also the first since 1984 to cross the halfway mark by itself and the Congress not even having enough seats to automatically be given the Leader of the Opposition post, there were genuine concerns about unbridled majoritarianism. Where would the opposition to the BJP come from?

Since the Congress continues to occupy the muddled middle and has pinned all its hopes on  Rajya Sabha numbers, where it has more seats than the BJP, the answer actually turns out to be an unusual combination of players both to the right and the left of the BJP. From labour law reform to the introduction of further foreign direct investment in insurance, it is BJP-affiliated organisations making common cause with pro-labour and Leftist outfits that have caused the most headaches for the new government.

With the Left and Right managing to converge on swadeshi issues, those who fall more in the pro-market camp within the BJP — many of whom were seen as the intellectual leaders of the campaign that brought Prime Minister Narendra Modi to power — are starting to get disconcerted with  government’s actions.

FDI in insurance

This appears to be the new government’s first big legislative battle, as the opposition parties have attempted to use their superior numbers in the Rajya Sabha to stand in the way of an attempt to increase the foreign direct investment cap in insurance from 26% to 49%. The government can resort to a joint sitting of the houses to bulldoze its legislation through the Parliament, but it is the reaction from trade unions and state insurance companies that has got the BJP concerned.

Crucially, the Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh, the BJP-affiliated organisation that counts itself as the largest centrally organised trade union in the country, has joined forces with an array of other labour organisations as well as employees of state insurance corporations in threatening to strike if the cap is raised. The communist parties have always been staunch opponents of additional foreign investment. They have now come together with outfits like the BMS to prevent a move that finance minister Arun Jaitley has said is crucial to help reinvigorate economic activity.

Genetically modified crops

Shortly after representatives of the Swadeshi Jagran Manch and the Bharatiya Kisan Sangh met with environment minister Prakash Javadekar, he announced that the government was putting field trials of the genetically modified crops on hold. The news prompted loud howls from many who believe GM crops are important for Indian agriculture to take its next step forward. But it was welcomed by both the Sangh Parivar organisations that had met Javadekar as well as by many on the Left who have sought to halt GM crops for years now.

Swadeshi education

The Akhil Bharatiya Vidya Parishad, the BJP’s Youth Wing, sensed during last year’s Delhi University Student Union elections that opposition to the new Four Year Undergraduate Programme could be a key plank in remaining popular on campus. Incidentally, the FYUP had been opposed by the more left-wing organisations on campus from the very get-go, so the ABVP joined up with them to call for a roll-back of the four-year programme. The agitation quickly became a national issue, and eventually the FYUP was rolled back.

This ABVP-Left combine has now re-emerged in the agitation against the Union Public Service Commission’s Common Scholastic Aptitude Test, which is being fought on grounds that it is biased towards urban students. Yet again, the combined forces have managed to extract a concession from the government — despite opposition from the more reformist sections of the BJP.

Labour law reforms

Trade unions from across the country are meeting this week to try and decide how to approach the issue of labour law reforms, after the Rajasthan government last month passed legislation that made it easier for companies to retrench employees. These unions include both those on the Left, including the Communist Party of India (Marxist)-backed Centre of Indian Trade Unions  as well as the BJP-affiliated Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh. Any decision to strike or launch a nationwide campaign by these groups could have a significant impact on a government that has insisted it is working primarily for the poor.

Foreign relations

The Modi government’s decision to vote against Israel at a United Nations forum shocked many supporters, who believe that India must be stand with Tel Aviv and remain steadfast against Islamic terrorism. It came as a pleasant surprise to those on the Left, however, who have always pushed India to speak up for those who live under Israeli occupation in Gaza and the West Bank.

The foreign relations convergence of the Left and Right was given a bigger boost after the Modi government decided to stand in the way of the World Trade Organisation’s Bali Package. Although the two factions here are unlikely to work together in pressuring the government to make decisions, particularly in the neighbourhood, the pressure to keep India relatively insulated from the West is likely to gain purchase from both sides.

via Scroll.in – News. Politics. Culture..

07/08/2014

One lakh children go missing in India every year: Home ministry – The Times of India

On February 5, 2013, a Supreme Court bench, angry over 1.7 lakh missing children and the government’s apathy towards the issue, had remarked: “Nobody seems to care about missing children. This is the irony.”  (Ed note: 1 lakh = 100,000)

English: Children in Raisen district (Bhil tri...

English: Children in Raisen district (Bhil tribe), MP, India. Français : Enfants dans le district de Raisen (tribu Bhil), M.P., Inde. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Close to one and a half years later, government data show over 1.5 lakh more children have gone missing, and the situation remains the same with an average of 45% of them remaining untraced.

Data on missing children put out by the home ministry last month in Parliament show that over 3.25 lakh children went missing between 2011 and 2014 (till June) at an average of nearly 1 lakh children going missing every year.

Compare this to our trouble-torn neighbour Pakistan where according to official figures around 3,000 children go missing every year. If population is an issue, then one could look at China, the most populous nation, where official figures put the number of missing children at around 10,000 every year.

National Crime Records Bureau, in fact, deciphers missing children figures in India in terms of one child going missing in the country every eight minutes.

More worryingly, 55% per cent of those missing are girls and 45% of all missing children have remained untraceable as yet raising fears of them having been either killed or pushed into begging or prostitution rackets.

Maharashtra is one of the worst states in terms of missing children with over 50,000 having disappeared in the past three and half years. Madhya Pradesh, Delhi and Andhra Pradesh are distant competitors with all recording less than 25,000 missing children for the period.

Worryingly, however, all these states have more missing girls than boys. In Maharashtra, 10,000 more girls went missing than boys. In Andhra Pradesh, the number of girls missing (11,625) is almost double of boys (6,915). Similarly, Madhya Pradesh has over 15,000 girls missing compared to around 9,000 boys. Delhi, too, has more girls (10,581) missing compared to boys (9,367).

via One lakh children go missing in India every year: Home ministry – The Times of India.

07/08/2014

These ten historical monuments earn India the most revenue

As airfares become cheaper and the world gets more adventurous, India’s tourism sector has been reaping the benefits. Revenues are expected to rise by 7.9% over the next decade. In 2012, according to the World Travel and Tourism Council, tourism accounted for 6.6% of India’s GDP.

Here’s a list of India’s most lucrative historical sites, based on the revenues they earned in 2013-2014.

1) Taj Mahal, Agra

Revenue: Rs. 21,84,88,950

Mughal emperor Shah Jahan’s marble tribute to third wife, Mumtaz Mahal, the Taj is by far the most iconic structure in India, as well as the country’s biggest-earning monument.

2) Qutab Minar complex, Delhi

Revenue: Rs 10,16,05,890

The Qutub Minar was built in the early 13th century and is the second-tallest tower in India (after Mohali’s Fateh Burj). It is made out of red and buff sandstone and is a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

3) Agra Fort, Agra

Revenue: Rs 10,22,56,790

Agra Fort, another UNESCO World Heritage site, was constructed under the third Mughal emperor Akbar over the remains of the ancient site known as Badalgarh.

4) Humayun’s Tomb, Delhi

Revenue: Rs 7,12,88,110

The tomb of the Mughal emperor Humayun was built in 1572 by his widow, Bega begum.

5) Red Fort, Delhi

Revenue: Rs 6,15,89,750

The Red Fort was originally built as the fortified palace of Shahjahanabad under Shah Jahan. It was the residence of the Mughal emperors for nearly 200 years.

6) Group of monuments, Fatehpur Sikri

Revenue: Rs 5,62,14,640

The city of Fatehpur Sikri was founded in 1569 by the Mughal emperor Akbar. It served as his capital from 1571 until 1585.

7) Group of monuments at Mahabalipuram

Revenue: Rs 2,72,93,480

The sculpted temples and buildings in this town, 60 kms south of Chennai, are the remains of a port from where ancient Indian traders travelled to South East Asia.

8) Sun Temple, Konarak

Damien Roué/Flickr

Revenue: Rs 2,43,52,060

This 13th-century temple in Odisha was conceived of as a gigantic solar chariot with 12 pairs of exquisitely-ornamented wheels pulled by seven rearing horses.

9) Group of temples, Khajuraho

Revenue: Rs 2,24,47,030

Khajuraho, in Madhya Pradesh, is synonymous with this large group of medieval Hindu and Jain temples, some of which have erotic sculptures.

10) Ellora Caves

Revenue: Rs 2,06,72,820

Ellora Caves are among the largest rock-hewn monastic-temple complexes in the entire world. The site includes one of the world’s largest monolithic structures, the Kailash temple.

via Scroll.in – News. Politics. Culture..

06/08/2014

Air India Loses Money to Dodge Giant Billboards in Mumbai – Businessweek

In the legion of problems that can beset an airline, here’s a novel one: gigantic billboards.

Super-sized advertisements stand in the flight path of Mumbai’s main airport, forcing departures to climb rapidly on takeoff. But Air India’s daily 15-hour flight to Newark, N.J., which requires a full load of fuel, would be too heavy to clear the billboard with its full load of passengers.

As a result, Air India now leaves 51 passengers off the Boeing (BA) 777-300ER. Flying 15 percent under capacity means losing 100 million rupees ($1.6 million) per month on the route, an Indian aviation minister told legislators on Monday, according to my Bloomberg News colleague, Anurag Kotoky.

Photograph by Dhiraj Singh for Businessweek.com

Airport officials at Chhatrapati Shivaji International have so far removed 13 of the 15 offending billboards in flight paths.

Air India has not reported a profit for eight years and required a government-funded rescue in 2012. United Airlines (UAL) uses a smaller 777-200 for the same route and has not experienced similar problems on departures, a spokeswoman told Bloomberg News.

via Air India Loses Money to Dodge Giant Billboards in Mumbai – Businessweek.

06/08/2014

Insurance Bill Struggle Pokes Another Hole in the Notion of Modi Magic – India Real Time – WSJ

The new government in New Delhi is struggling this week to get an insurance-industry liberalization bill— an important part of its campaign to revamp the economy—to the floor of the upper house of Parliament.

Opening up the insurance business to more foreign investment was one of the main deregulation measures unveiled in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s first budget last month.

But already it is bogged down. Mr. Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party does not control the upper house and other parties want to stall a vote on the bill.

The legislative tussle is a sign of the challenges Mr. Modi faces, despite his party’s landslide electoral victory and the BJP’s lower-house majority, as he tries to push through even modest changes in the way India manages its economy.

Mr. Modi swept to power this spring on a surge of anti-incumbency sentiment and hope that the BJP could break the policy deadlock in the capital. Supporters expected Mr. Modi bring the “achche din,” or good days, back to Asia’s third-largest economy.

But India’s complicated national politics, its decentralized federal system and Mr. Modi’s own desire not to get too far ahead of public opinion in a country long used to large-scale welfare schemes and a heavy state hand in the economy, is likely to slow any change.

The new administration’s national budget, announced in July, was bland and disappointing to many. It did not include the kind of big-bang reforms many optimists had anticipated.

In response to criticism of the budget, India’s new Finance Minister Arun Jaitley told a television news channel that the government is waiting for the right time to implement some changes.

“You don’t do reforms in a manner that the political system is unwilling to accept them,” Mr. Jaitley said during a July interview on Headlines Today. “The more challenging ones, you go on that course in times to come.”

Last week, Mr. Modi’s government blocked an important trade agreement that all 160 members of the World Trade Organization—including India—had agreed to in December. India demanding more freedom ratchet up market-distorting food subsidies.

“This is an inauspicious start for the new Modi government,” said Orrin Hatch, a Republican U.S. senator from Utah and member of the Senate Finance Committee in response to India’s decision.

M. J. Akbar, a BJP spokesman, says the party is happy with its progress. He said the government has focused on dealing with inflation, encouraging growth and reaching out to neighboring countries.

“On the insurance bill, the government has shown complete firmness in pushing it through,” and will use a joint-session of Parliament to vote on it if the upper house refuses, he said.

Still, the gradual deflation of the Modi bubble can be seen in the stock and currency markets. The benchmark Sensex index, has basically been going sideways for the last two months, after a sharp run up as the scale of Mr. Modi’s election win became clear.

The rupee has also been giving up some of this year’s gains against the dollar.

Of course the less excitable analysts and executives have always said the complexity of running the world’s largest democracy means that decision making will remain a slow and often painful process, even with a majority in the lower house of Parliament.

Many of the biggest challenges to improving the lives for India’s 1.2 billion citizens—such as reducing corruption, building modern infrastructure and providing hundreds of millions of good jobs–will take years, if not decades, surmount, even with the right policies and a charismatic leader.

“If a handful of people decide that (the progress so far) is insufficient, we have to ignore them and recognize that the majority of India is both relieved that the return of governance as well as the return of hope,” said the BJP’s Mr. Akbar. “Files are being cleared after ages of stagnation.”

–Prasanta Sahu contributed to this story.

via Insurance Bill Struggle Pokes Another Hole in the Notion of Modi Magic – India Real Time – WSJ.

06/08/2014

Scramble for Dalit votes is sparking increased communal violence in UP

The key force driving the increasing communal polarisation in Uttar Pradesh is the scramble for Dalit votes in an attempt to weaken the Bahujan Samaj Party and deter Muslims from rallying behind it.

This strategy was evolved, and implemented, during the last Lok Sabha elections. But the competition to woo Dalits has gathered momentum ahead of bypolls to 12 assembly seats, five of which are in the western section of the state, which is often billed as the “wild west” of the Hindi heartland.

As the Indian Express reported, more than 600 incidents of communal violence have taken place in the state since May.

The Bharatiya Janata Party’s stake in the bypolls, which have yet to be scheduled, is enormous. Eleven of the 12 constituencies here had BJP MLAs, all of whom were elected to the Lok Sabha, as was the party’s ally, Apna Dal leader Anupriya Patel. The results will help measure the durability of the Modi wave, and its possible impact on the UP assembly elections in early 2017.  The verdict from UP could well determine the chances of Prime Minister Narendra Modi winning a second successive term in the 2019 polls.

The need to cobble together an electoral majority is driving political parties to resort to communal mobilisation. Local disputes over land, civic amenities, and exploitative gender relations have been given a communal hue and magnified to portray a monolith Hindu community arrayed against the Muslims.

via Scroll.in – News. Politics. Culture..

06/08/2014

Key questions that have been lost in the din of protests against the civil services exam

In the midst of protests against the new format of the civil services examination, several key issues have gone unaddressed. An opportunity for meaningful debate about the exam has quickly turned into a slanging match.

The matter has assumed an unnecessarily adversarial tone, with English pitted against other Indian languages. But the issues are far more complex and far less binary than politicians believe. Here are some key questions that have got lost in the din.

Should the Civil Services Aptitude Test be scrapped altogether?

The answer is a clear no. The CSAT gauges logical reasoning, problem-solving skills, analytical abilities, basic numeracy and English proficiency up to class 10 level. To argue that an administrator can do without any of these skills is unrealistic. An administrator has to deal with huge amounts of quantitative and qualitative information and any deficiency in these skills would mean a sub-par performance on the job.

Does the CSAT discriminate against students doing the exam in Hindi or regional languages?

No, but it does employ very poor translation software. The Union Public Service Commission, which conducts the exam, must acquire competent translators or purchase translation software that is up to the mark. This should do the trick.

Is there a grain of truth in what the protestors are alleging?

At the heart of the uproar lies the allegation that the exam is biased towards those who take the exam in English. Since the revised format came into force in 2011, the number of students who take the exam in Hindi has steadily fallen. (However, to really judge whether this is significant, one would have to look not at the absolute numbers of successful candidates who do the exam in Hindi, but the percentage of such candidates out of all those who take the exam in Hindi. But data about the number of test takers in each language is not available).

There may be a kernel of truth to this claim. But the blame lies to a large extent with the coaching and publishing industry. There is simply not enough study material available in Hindi and other regional languages. It is this paucity of study material that hurts students from vernacular backgrounds in the long run.

Surely, pelting stones and burning vehicles is not acceptable behaviour?

Some protestors, by resorting to violence, have demonstrated their unsuitability for the job. It is safe to say that many students have spent hundreds of hours preparing for the exam in its current format. What about their efforts? Do they count for nothing? By taking to the streets and letting political players into the mix, the protestors have probably done more harm than good.

Does the civil services exam in its current format select the best and the brightest?

Opinions differ considerably. An IAS probationer who did not want to be named told this writer: “The civil service exams, in its existing format, put less emphasis on rote learning and that is a good thing. The less this examination focuses on retention of information, the better.”

The civil services exam in its current format has three key components. The prelims, the mains and the interview. The first stage of the exam is the prelims, which has two parts, of which the second is the dreaded CSAT. As argued earlier, however, the CSAT is essential for ensuring that only candidates who possess minimum competencies and skill sets make it through to the far more difficult second round, the mains.

The Union Public Service Commission, with its recent revision in format for the mains, has reduced much of the burden on students. Earlier, a student had to master two subjects of their choice (neither of which he or she may have studied before). But now a student just has to choose just one subject of his or her choice. By emphasising general studies and critical thinking, the UPSC has levelled the playing field to a large degree.

How about allowing lateral entry?

The UPSC could also perhaps increase the number of vacancies in the civil services. It is a fact that we don’t have enough administrators for the population. According to various media reports, Right to Information applications and 2011 census figures, India has slightly more than 1,600 government servants for every 100,000 residents, which many studies say is a low ratio.

If quality of candidates is an issue, then the UPSC could look into the lateral entry of specialists, and even pay them market wages, a system used in the developed world. India’s political establishment must separate policy functions from service delivery and stop interference in operational matters. Simultaneously, the political class must establish uniform standards and guidelines across the country.

via Scroll.in – News. Politics. Culture..

Law of Unintended Consequences

continuously updated blog about China & India

ChiaHou's Book Reviews

continuously updated blog about China & India

What's wrong with the world; and its economy

continuously updated blog about China & India